• हिन्दी
  • ગુજરાતી
  • বাংলা
  • తెలుగు
  • मराठी
  • ಕನ್ನಡ
  • money9
  • Insurance
  • Saving
  • Mutual Funds
  • Mirae Asset MF
  • Breaking Briefs
downloadDownload The App
Close
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Podcast
  • Banking
  • Bulletin
  • Gold
  • Healthcare
  • Real Estate
  • Tax
  • Travel
  • Survey 2023
  • Survey Report
  • Breaking Briefs
  • Insurance
  • Savings
  • Loan
  • Crypto
  • Investment
  • Mutual Funds
  • Real Estate
  • Tax
  • Exclusive
  • Home / Investment

Tax planning that benefits taxpayers not illegal, rules ITAT

ITAT held that long-term capital loss (LTCL) from one asset class may be set off against gains from another asset class.

  • Himali Patel
  • Last Updated : September 28, 2021, 13:21 IST
  • Follow
ITAT held that LTCL arising from a particular asset class could be set off against LTCG arising from another asset class.
  • Follow

If you are a tax-paying investor, you would probably know that capital gain occurs when you sell a capital asset for more than you paid for it. Stocks, bonds, precious metals, jewellery, and real estate are all examples of capital assets.  That said, capital gains are taxed differently depending on how long you held the asset before selling it. Long-term capital gains (LTCG) are taxed differently than short-term capital gains (STCG).

As per the provisions of the Income Tax Act, 1961, (IT Act), Short Term Capital Loss (STCL) of the current year can be set off both against STCG and LTCG. However, Long Term Capital Loss (LTCL) of the current year can only be set off against LTCG. Similar is the case with the carry forward and set of STCL and LTCL in subsequent years.

However, the issue came to the limelight when recently the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) determined that tax planning is not “illegal” and should not be overlooked by tax authorities just because it benefits taxpayers.

Case study

The issue of setting off losses from shares against gains from the sale of property rose to prominence due to a recent judgment of the Mumbai Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) in the case of Michael E Desa versus Income Tax Officer International Taxation.

In this case, ITAT held that LTCL arising from a particular asset class could be set off against LTCG arising from another asset class. In this case, the assessee was an NRI who sold a property in India and earned LTCG. At the same time, he sold some shares of an unlisted company and incurred LTCL.

Michael E Desa is a non-resident Indian. He sold a property in the previous year in which he was a 50% co-owner and declared a long-term capital gain of Rs 95,12,556.  Additionally, he also disclosed Rs 1,11,87,578 long-term capital loss on the sale of certain shares in VCAM Investment Managers Pvt Ltd. (VCAM). According to the Assessing Officer, “the (this) long term capital loss was attributed on the basis of equity shares of VCAM (Investment Managers Pvt Ltd), which appear to be prima facie fraudulent and not allowable against any taxable income.”

“The Assessing Officer was of the view that LTCL on account of sale of equity shares of a company primarily appears to be fictitious and hence, is not entitled to be adjusted against any taxable income. According to the judgment, the Assessing Officer has primarily questioned the timing of booking the loss and selling these shares, which, even according to the Assessing Officer, are “worthless,” explained Suresh Surana, Founder, RSM India.

That said, The ITAT ruled that it is not for the Assessing Officer to take a call on how an assessee should organise his fiscal affairs to serve the interests of the revenue authorities.

“The Assessing Officer cannot disregard a transaction just because it results in a tax advantage to the assessee. Just as much as we cannot legitimize and glorify tax evasion through colourable devices and tax shelters, we cannot also deprecate and disapprove genuine tax planning within the framework of law,” said Surana.

“The most crucial thing is to understand that this judgment reiterates the principle that legitimate tax planning within the four corners of law by set-off of LTCL on sale of shares against the LTCG on sale of immovable property or vice versa is permissible,” pointed out Surana.

As per the experts to understand the context of the question, it is important to note that there has not been any change with respect to the provisions of set-off of capital losses against capital gains in the recent past.

In the end, this benefits individuals to legitimately reduce their tax liability by booking their LTCL and setting it off against the LTCG, and hence the above jurisprudence supports this position.

Published: September 28, 2021, 13:08 IST

Download Money9 App for the latest updates on Personal Finance.

  • income tax
  • investments
  • LTCG

Related

  • पहली छमाही में रियल एस्टेट में संस्थागत निवेश 37% घटकर तीन अरब डॉलर रहने का अनुमान
  • Budget’24: New LTCG rule to hit long-term property owners hard
  • Looking to buy gold? Buy now before it’s too late!
  • Budget 2024: What is NPS ‘Vatsalya’ scheme? How to apply & other benefits?
  • Budget’ 24: Startup ecosystem all smiles with scrapping of angel tax
  • Budget’24: New NPS scheme for minors launched, here’s how you can benefit

Latest

  • 1. Know the correct way to get KYC done!
  • 2. Why health insurance claim gets rejected?
  • 3. Power to Respond!
  • 4. What is Asset Under Management?
  • 5. No Worries on Medical Expenses!
  • Trending Stories

  • शुद्ध प्रत्यक्ष कर संग्रह चालू वित्त वर्ष में अबतक 1.34 प्रतिशत घटकर 5.63 लाख करोड़ रुपये पर
  • अदाणी ग्रीन एनर्जी की नवीकरणीय ऊर्जा क्षमता जून तिमाही में 45 प्रतिशत बढ़ी
  • विदेशी मुद्रा भंडार तीन अरब डॉलर घटकर 699.74 अरब डॉलर पर
  • टेस्ला की भारतीय बाजार में दस्तक, अगले सप्ताह मुंबई में खोलेगी स्टोर
  • दुर्लभ खनिज उत्पादन के लिए 1,345 करोड़ रुपये की प्रोत्साहन योजना का प्रस्ताव: कुमारस्वामी
  • TV9 Sites

  • TV9 Hindi
  • TV9Telugu.com
  • TV9 Marathi
  • TV9 Gujarati
  • TV9 Kannada
  • TV9 Bangla
  • News9 Live
  • Trends9
  • Tv9tamilnews
  • Assamtv9
  • Malayalamtv9
  • Money9 Sites

  • Money9 Hindi
  • Money9 English
  • Money9 Marathi
  • Money9 Telugu
  • Money9 Gujarati
  • Money9 Kannada
  • Money9 Bangla
  • Money9live
  • Topics

  • Insurance
  • Savings
  • Loan
  • Stocks
  • Mutual Funds
  • Real Estate
  • Tax
  • Crypto
  • Exclusive
  • Follow us

  • FaceBook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Download App

  • play_store
  • App_store
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Privacy & Cookies Notice
  • Complaint Redressal
  • Copyright © 2025 Money9. All rights reserved.
  • share
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Whatsapp
  • LinkedIn
  • Telegram
close